Case supports deviation from federal guidelines – Nathalie Boutet in Law Times

Creative child support arrangements that stray from the Child Support Guidelines work in certain cases, but some parties prefer to stick with the federal system due to its enforcement powers, Toronto family lawyer Nathalie Boutet tells Law Times.

The article discusses a recent case, Stevenson v. Smit, where the parties recorded an intention to equally share the major expenses for their children in a separation agreement, but after three years, the father defaulted and alleged he could no longer meet the terms of the agreement.

It’s significant, says Boutet, because the arrangements were created in a way that made a lot of sense at the time of negotiation.

“It highlights that people can be creative for the benefit of the children but it has to make sense,” she says in Law Times.

“The husband was uncomfortable making a commitment on a monthly basis because of his low income. This worked well and gave him the freedom to get on with his life. The court told him to keep doing it. When it is no longer suiting your purpose, you can’t renege on a bargain made in full contemplation of your financial future. The court is saying: ‘If you don’t manage your property so your wife can get what you agreed, that’s your problem,’” Boutet says in the publication.

With her practice focusing on mediation, collaboration, and negotiation, Boutet says she often makes arrangements that deviate from the guidelines, “but there has been a fear that the support payer won’t honour his or her obligations.”

While the guidelines have their place in the legal system, Boutet says she welcomes the opportunity to veer away from them.

“With the increasingly frequent shared-parenting arrangement, the (guideline) does not provide a proper straight-line answer,” she tells Law Times. “We need something more creative. People don’t want to deal with each other yearly.”

Read the Full Article Here

Share on

Posted in Financial Issues

Register for our newsletter

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Take the first step

Let us help you navigate this challenging time with expertise, compassion and strategic thinking.

Complete the form below or call us directly at 416-408-0444.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We are dedicated to supporting our clients through Collaborative Divorce and Mediated Divorce, prioritizing their needs every step of the way.

32+ Years of Experience

With more than 32 years of experience, Nathalie has successfully represented thousands of clients, helping them to achieve their goals with her expertise, compassion, and strategic thinking.

No-charge initial call

We understand you have questions and need guidance on your next step. We will contact you to schedule a brief initial call to discuss your situation and our services.

Committed to effective and respectful family dispute resolution

Nathalie has expertise handling all family matters including situations involving business owners, executives, and professionals; situations challenged by difficult personalities and complex personal and financial circumstances; and working with families facing addiction challenges.